I recently replaced my 10x20 ShelterLogic carport with this 10x15. The old one suffered collapse after a heavy snowfall. The 15 foot length worked better for my application, but that size was difficult to find. I was fortunate to find this one and constructed it this week.
It seems to be of sufficient build to withstand the rain and moderate winds. I have taken measures to strengthen it against the wind. I used a double thickness of composite decking, anchored to the pad with concrete bolts. The feet were then screwed to the decking. The supplied cord was tied tightly between the top of the legs and the foot. Additionally, stronger cord was tied out at an angle to firm anchors around the periphery. Note that the supplied anchors not substantial and are sufficient only for very light winds. I expect this to last several years barring falling limbs or excess snowfall. I fully expect to need to replace the top due to effects of the sun every few years. I am hoping that Caravan will continue to have this available in the future.
Let's call it a 4.5 star. Would have been 5 with more beefy tie downs. For the price, a solid 4.5.